Have you ever dropped a plate and watched it shatter, taking your dinner plans down?
We’ve all been there. Whether you’re setting up your first home or looking to replace your worn-out dinnerware, choosing between hardened and durable plates can feel overwhelming.
With so many options on the market – from everyday ceramic to fancy porcelain – how do you know which ones will last?
Many of us have spent good money on plates that promised to be “unbreakable,” only to end up with chipped edges and scratched surfaces months later.
But here’s the thing: understanding the real differences between hardened and durable plates could save you both money and frustration.
Let’s explore what makes each type special, and most importantly, which is right for your home.
- UNDERSTANDING THE BASICS: WHAT SETS THEM APART
- HARDENED PLATES: THE SCIENCE BEHIND THE STRENGTH
- DURABLE PLATES: BUILT TO LAST
- EXAMPLES OF HARDENED AND DURABLE PLATES
- CARE INSTRUCTIONS SPECIFIC TO EXAMPLES
- THE MANUFACTURING PROCESS: A TALE OF TWO TECHNIQUES
- PERFORMANCE UNDER PRESSURE: REAL-WORLD TESTING
- MAKING THE RIGHT CHOICE: FACTORS TO CONSIDER
- MAINTENANCE REQUIREMENTS
- INVESTMENT AND VALUE PROPOSITION
- CARE AND MAINTENANCE TIPS
- MAKING YOUR FINAL DECISION
- WHAT IS THE BEST MATERIAL FOR UNBREAKABLE PLATES?
- WHAT IS THE STRONGEST TYPE OF DINNERWARE?
- WHAT ARE HARD PLASTIC PLATES CALLED?
- WHAT IS UNBREAKABLE DINNERWARE CALLED?
- WHAT IS THE MOST DURABLE DINNERWARE MATERIAL?
- CONCLUSION
UNDERSTANDING THE BASICS: WHAT SETS THEM APART
When diving into the world of dinnerware, it’s crucial to understand that not all plates are created equal.
While exploring various types of dinnerware, we discover that the terms “hardened” and “durable” often get tossed around interchangeably, but they represent distinct characteristics that can significantly impact your dining experience.
HARDENED PLATES: THE SCIENCE BEHIND THE STRENGTH
Hardened plates undergo a specific manufacturing process that enhances their resistance to scratches and chips.
According to the British Ceramic Confederation, these plates typically go through a tempering process where they’re heated to extremely high temperatures and then rapidly cooled.
This process creates a compressed surface layer that’s significantly more resistant to mechanical stress.
Key characteristics include:
– Enhanced scratch resistance
– Better chip resistance
– Higher thermal shock resistance
– Typically thinner profile while maintaining strength.
DURABLE PLATES: BUILT TO LAST
Durable plates, on the other hand, focus on overall longevity and resistance to daily wear and tear.
While comparing ceramic and porcelain dishes, we find that durability often comes from the material composition and manufacturing techniques that prioritize thickness and impact resistance.
Primary features include:
– Superior impact resistance
– Excellent heat retention
– Greater weight and thickness
– Enhanced stability
[ NOTE: The characteristics of durable dishes highlighted above don’t mean that hardened dishes don’t have some of the same qualities but it depends on your usage and maintenance culture].
EXAMPLES OF HARDENED AND DURABLE PLATES
HARDENED PLATES EXAMPLES
1. Corelle Vitrelle Glass Plates
– Material: Tempered glass (triple-layer glass laminate)
– Notable features:
– Extremely chip and break resistant
– Lightweight
– Thermal shock resistant
– Stackable without scratching
– Best for: Daily use in households that want elegant but durable options
2. Arc International Tempered Glass Plates
– Material: Fully tempered soda lime glass
– Notable features:
– Heat resistant up to 140°C
– Scratch-resistant surface
– Thin profile
– Elegant appearance
– Best for: Restaurant settings and sophisticated home dining
3. Duralex Tempered Glass Collection
– Material: Tempered glass
– Notable features:
– Impact and chip resistant
– Can withstand sudden temperature changes
– 2.5 times stronger than ordinary glass
– Lightweight yet sturdy
– Best for: Family households with children
4. Luminarc Tempered Glass Plates
– Material: Tempered glass with a hardened surface
– Notable features:
– High resistance to mechanical shock
– Thermal shock resistant
– Non-porous surface
– Hygienic and easy to clean
– Best for: Modern homes and casual dining settings
DURABLE PLATES EXAMPLES
– Material: Fully vitrified china with high-fire glaze
– Notable features:
– Extra thick construction
– Chip resistant
– Slightly heavyweight for stability
– Microwave and dishwasher safe
– Best for: Busy restaurants and heavy-duty home use
– Material: Stoneware with reinforced composition
– Notable features:
– Extremely durable construction
– Excellent heat retention
– Heavy-duty glaze
– Resistant to daily wear
– Best for: Long-term family use and traditional settings
Finally, the Denby dinnerware brand is a perfect example of stoneware dinnerware made in the USA.
3. Churchill Super Vitrified Plates
– Material: Super vitrified china
– Notable features:
– Commercial-grade durability
– Edge chip warranty
– Thermal shock resistant
– Heavy-duty construction
– Best for: Commercial kitchens and high-traffic environments
4. Steelite Performance Collection
– Material: Fully vitrified ceramic
– Notable features:
– Maximum impact resistance
– Thermal shock resistant
– Edge chipping resistance
– Superior body strength
– Best for: Professional food service and heavy-use environments
COMPARISON OF KEY CHARACTERISTICS
| Brand Example | Weight | Edge Strength | Temperature Resistance | Best Use Case |
| Corelle Vitrelle | Light | High | Very High | Daily Home Use |
| Arc International | Light | High | High | Elegant Dining |
| Fiesta | Heavy | High | High | Family Dining and Commercial Use |
| Denby | Heavy | Very High | Very High | Family Dining |
CARE INSTRUCTIONS SPECIFIC TO EXAMPLES
For Hardened Plates:
1. Corelle & Arc International:
– Safe for microwave and dishwasher
– Avoid sudden temperature changes
– Stack with minimal spacing needed
For Durable Plates:
2. Denby & Churchill:
– Microwave and dishwasher safe
– Can handle temperature variations
– Stack carefully despite durability
– Use standard cleaning products
THE MANUFACTURING PROCESS: A TALE OF TWO TECHNIQUES
Understanding how these plates are made helps explain their distinct properties.
Let’s break down the manufacturing processes:
Hardened Plate Production
1. Initial forming of the base material
2. Primary firing at 800-1000°C ( differ with brands)
3. Glazing application
4. Secondary firing at higher temperatures
5. Tempering process for surface hardening
Durable Plate Production
1. Material selection (often including reinforced compounds)
2. Thick-body forming
3. Single high-temperature firing
4. Specialized glazing for additional protection
PERFORMANCE UNDER PRESSURE: REAL-WORLD TESTING
When it comes to evaluating dinnerware quality, manufacturers conduct comprehensive testing to assess durability and performance.
Industry-standard tests typically examine multiple aspects of plate durability, from impact resistance to thermal shock handling.
Based on standard testing protocols, here’s how hardened and durable plates generally compare:
| Test Category | Hardened Plates | Durable Plates |
| Drop Impact | Excellent but depends on distance or height | Good but depends on distance or height |
| Scratch Resistance | Excellent | Good |
| Thermal Shock | Excellent | Good |
| Daily Wear | Good (depends on use) | Good (depends on use) |
| Weight | Lighter | Heavier |
These test results reflect typical performance patterns seen across major manufacturers’ product lines.
The testing criteria help consumers understand the practical differences between these two plate categories and make informed decisions based on their specific needs.
In addition, in terms of knowing the drop test conducted by Safekitchn with regards to Corelle and IKEA dishes, kindly read our guide on the difference between Corelle and IKEA Oftast dinnerware brands.
MAKING THE RIGHT CHOICE: FACTORS TO CONSIDER
When selecting between hardened and durable plates, consider these key factors:
Usage Patterns
– Family with young children? Hardened or Durable plates might be your best bet (depending on the brand you decide to go with)
– Regular entertainer? Hardened plates offer elegance without compromising too much on strength
– Professional setting? Consider the balance between presentation and practicality.
MAINTENANCE REQUIREMENTS
Hardened plates typically require:
– Gentle handling despite their strength
– Specific storage conditions
– Careful stacking to prevent surface contact
Durable plates need:
– Regular inspection for glazing wear
– Standard cleaning procedures
– Less particular storage requirements
INVESTMENT AND VALUE PROPOSITION
When considering the long-term value:
Hardened Plates:
– Higher initial cost (depends on the dinnerware brand, product design, and model)
– Excellent longevity with proper care
– Better retention of appearance
– Premium market positioning
Durable Plates:
– Moderate initial investment
– Outstanding longevity in high-stress environments
– May show wear more visibly
– Practical value proposition
CARE AND MAINTENANCE TIPS
To maximize the lifespan of your chosen dinnerware:
For Hardened Plates:
1. Avoid sudden temperature changes
2. Use soft cleaning materials
3. Store with protective layers between pieces
4. Handle from the base, not the rim
For Durable Plates:
1. Regular inspection for signs of wear
2. Standard dishwasher safe practices
3. Stack carefully despite durability
4. Avoid excessive impact despite strength
MAKING YOUR FINAL DECISION
Consider your lifestyle, usage patterns, and aesthetic preferences when making your choice.
Remember that both options offer distinct advantages, and the “perfect” choice depends entirely on your specific needs.
A Quick Decision Guide:
Choose Hardened Plates if you:
– Prioritize simple food presentation
– Have carefree handling habits
– Want scratch-resistant surfaces
– Prefer lighter-weight options
Choose Durable Plates if you:
– Need minimum impact resistance
– Wants to make a statement with your food presentation
– Have a not-so-busy household
– Value stability over weight
WHAT IS THE BEST MATERIAL FOR UNBREAKABLE PLATES?
Melamine is the best material for unbreakable plates, offering superior impact resistance and durability.
For those preferring non-plastic options, tempered glass (like Corelle) provides excellent break resistance while maintaining a more premium feel.
WHAT IS THE STRONGEST TYPE OF DINNERWARE?
Vitrified porcelain is the strongest type of dinnerware. It undergoes intense heating that eliminates porosity, creating an extremely dense and durable material resistant to chips, cracks, and breakage.
Commercial-grade vitrified porcelain used in restaurants offers maximum durability.
WHAT ARE HARD PLASTIC PLATES CALLED?
Hard plastic plates are called Melamine dinnerware. This thermosetting plastic combines durability with style and is commonly used in casual dining, outdoor settings, and children’s tableware.
WHAT IS UNBREAKABLE DINNERWARE CALLED?
Unbreakable dinnerware is called tempered dinnerware or vitrified dinnerware.
Common examples include Corelle (tempered glass) and high-fired vitrified porcelain.
These materials undergo special hardening processes to enhance their break resistance.
WHAT IS THE MOST DURABLE DINNERWARE MATERIAL?
Super-vitrified porcelain is the most durable dinnerware material. Created through high-temperature firing (over 1,200°C), it features:
– Zero porosity
– Maximum impact resistance
– Superior chip resistance
– Excellent thermal shock tolerance
– Enhanced edge strength
CONCLUSION
The choice between hardened and durable plates ultimately comes down to understanding your specific needs and usage patterns.
Both options offer excellent solutions for different situations, and neither is universally “better” than the other.
Consider your lifestyle, dining habits, and aesthetic preferences when making your decision.
With a passion for culinary delights and 8 years of expertise in the dinnerware Industry, I've curated a collection that blends style with safety and functionality.
Explore the world of exceptional dining experiences with me as your guide.
- IKEA Outdoor Dinnerware - January 23, 2025
- IKEA Dinera Mug - January 22, 2025
- IKEA 365 Dishes - January 21, 2025